The first box arrived Thursday. Inside were seven picture books. I’ve been told to expect about 175 more before the January 15 deadline, from which my fellow judges and I will select the 2019 winners of the Margaret Wise Brown Prize, and an honor award.
I’ve never judged a picture book contest before, but by virtue of having won the Margaret Wise Brown honor this year with Little Wolf’s First Howling, I was asked to help choose next year’s winners.
My fellow judges are Elaine Magliaro, who authored this year’s prize winner, Things to Do, and E.B. Lewis, a five-time Coretta Scott King award-winning illustrator of 70-plus books for children. Over the next months we will read and note our responses to the submitted books and figure out how to work with each other as we wend our way to a decision.
Presented annually by Hollins University in Roanoke, VA, the Margaret Wise Brown Prize recognizes the author of the best text for a picture book published during the previous year. The award is a tribute to one of Hollins’ best-known alumnae and one of America’s most beloved children’s authors. Winners are given a $1,000 cash prize, which comes from an endowed fund created by James Rockefeller, Brown’s fiancé at the time of her death. It makes sense that the award is for text, since Margaret herself was the author of all those wonderful classics, not the illustrator.
This focus on text contrasts with the ALA’s Caldecott which is “awarded annually to the artist of the most distinguished American picture book for children published by an American publisher in the United States in English during the preceding year.” (from ALA site, emphasis mine)
I will have as hard a time considering text without illustrations as I would considering illustrations without text. I think these two ways of telling must work together to serve the story in a picture book. It will be interesting to see how my thinking about this progresses. In fact, I am eager for the education this experience will offer.
I look forward to reading the 2018 crop of picture books — and to sharing my favorites with friends and family.
I did this a few years ago for the SCBWI Golden Kite award. It, too, is for picture book text and involved several hundred picture books. It’s wonderful t get all those lovely books, and really, really hard to choose among them!
Oh how fun I’m sure there some small ones around who can listen to you read ☺️ And give you feedback
What a cool and daunting responsibility! Have fun and best of luck as you choose your favorites!
Congratulations on your award and the honor to be a 2019 judge! Happy reading! Linda Harris
It took me a few years to find this post Laura, but many belated congratulations. I teach in the Hollins Childrens Lit and illustration program and designed and hand colored your award certificate. I’m sharing this blog post with my current picture book writing class.
Thanks for your coloring, Ashley! and best to you in these